The vast majority of self-invested pension providers view the Lifetime ISA as a “direct attack” on the pension industry, a survey by the Association Of Member Directed Pension Schemes (AMPS) has found (Pensions Advice Bristol).
Almost nine out of 10 of the 89 AMPS members surveyed said the new ISA, which was announced by Chancellor George Osborne in the March Budget, would undermine pensions.
The Lifetime ISA gives savers aged less than 40 the option of using the money saved in the wrapper as a deposit on a first home, or towards their retirement. Investors can save up to £4,000 each year in a Lifetime ISA and receive a government bonus of 25 per cent, that is a bonus of up to £1,000 a year.
Mr Osborne’s announcement has led some in the industry to express concerns that it will encourage people to opt out of auto-enrolment.
Paul Lindfield, director at a Manchester based wealth management firm, agreed the Lifetime ISA is “a threat” to pensions, but added “most AMPS members in SIPPS and Ssas tend to be owners and directors of businesses that are seeking professional advice and will be guided away from Lifetime ISAs.
But Ian Gwinnell, an independent financial adviser, said the pensions industry was “overreacting” to the introduction of the Lifetime ISA.
He said “I fear nothing by what has come about through the Lifetime ISA,” he told Financial Adviser. “From the research we’ve done, pensions tax relief provides much better value than Lifetime ISA.”
Mr Gwinnell also down played concerns that younger people who can’t afford professional advice would opt for the more tangible, if “ultimately inferior,” benefits of a Lifetime ISA.
He said: “I appreciate there is a large proportion of the population that won’t get advice. But hopefully they will seek advice from their parents and other people who have had professional advice themselves.”
Back in March, Financial Adviser reported savers who decide to withdraw money early from the newly announced Lifetime ISA could suffer a hefty 24 per cent loss to their pot.
A managing director Ian Lowes pointed out if the funds are withdrawn before the age of 60 for any purpose other than purchasing a first property, then the penalty will be severe.
Withdrawal will result in the loss of the government bonus and any interest or investment growth on this, plus a 5 per cent charge.
This, he said, ultimately translates to a 24 per cent decide to withdraw money early from the newly announced Lifetime ISA could suffer a hefty 24 per cent loss to their pot.
This, he said, ultimately translates to a 24 per cent reduction in the savings, which he argued puts the investor in a worse position than if they had used a standard ISA.
As part of the AMPS member survey, SIPP and Ssas providers were also asked how they would vote in the upcoming referendum on whether to remain in the European Union.
A slim majority 51 per cent said they would vote to stay in the EU, while 31 per cent have yet to make up their mind.
Sixty-one per cent said they were bored of hearing about the Brexit.
(FTadviser, May, 2016)
Pensions Advice Bristol and Financial Advice Bristol
If you would like to speak with one of our Independent Financial Advisors and potentially receive financial advice, please contact us on 0117 923 7652. We are based in Clifton, Bristol but we are happy to service clients from across the UK and we provide free initial meetings at our client’s convenience.